From the CTS session about surveillance; I began thinking of social presence in different terms. Social presence of a woman compared to the sense of self, of queer people in social spaces and also the contrast between our social self compare to our online persona (an example would be influencers). All of this connects due to the constant monitoring of these people within society and social situations even though the visability of the individuals In these groups aren’t apparent when they need it. Im very keen in looking into the social media aspect of our social selves and how do followers come into play under the term of surveillance. More often than not Generation X will ‘complain’ that Instagram and social media is a load of rubbish as people are so much invested in it that it can be individuals only careers- this also led me to thinking how our sense of self can potentially be warped / manipulated by the environment of online culture.
Firstly, I wanted to explore the ideas between social identity and our own sense of self in terms of social media. Social media when you critically think about it is such a new development and creation within modern day technology- it has had such an impact on everyone within the world in any different ways and often not for the better depending on own personal experiences. When posting to the likes of instagram, you can control the way you are portrayed, what aesthetic of style you want to show off and also manipulate your body and face. For the likes of festival bloggers, in order to easily show off what you’re selling and promoting in order to earn more traffic and deals, more often than not these bloggers will saturate their photos, post colourful edits, use glitter effect filters to connote the popular trend of festival fashion. In October 2018 and article come out that was very striking to a lot of instagram users about how their favourite influencers have been caught out in faking an entire life style- this was very eye opening to a lot of readers and started a trend between you-tubers of trying to prank their subscribers and followers into thinking they went; on holiday, a festival, are rich etc.- This exposed the instagram reality of promotion and being an influencer. This makes a lot of sense as a large majority of festival influencers gain popularity for their shock value of what they’re wearing; Pants with bum cheeks cut out, wearing almost any dress to ‘go to the shops’, wearing nipple pasties for a day trip etc. All these attributes gain attention and following as the majoirty of the followers wouldn’t do that themselves / haven’t got the confidence to do this so instead follow them in order to see more extreme content. The reality of this though moving the surveillance of the followers and brand deals, a lot of these influencers are infact the same as their followers; they create this wild persona of people who aren’t scared to go out in just a bikini on a casual day but instead create this fake realty in exchange for more popularity and sponsorships. Of course this isn’t always the case- when being the likes of a festival blogger, the key is in the name to go to festivals and wear these outfits like a lot of them do, but festivals and summer events aren’t always around so what else is there to photograph and create in minus degree weather/ its too cold to go out in booty shorts and chaps. When your career is a niche online branch such as its important to keep up the persona / aesthetic otherwise you will eventually lose the crowd, sponsorships and endorsements yourecieve for posting such content.
Although this example is in terms of profit and majority business, this example follows suit in personal life. Through images you have the means to capture what you want people to see, you can play about with filter colour effects to create a mood to your photograph, its a skill of art. With this individuals with no agenda other than themselves can portray themselves in a particular way to other people. By this, I mean someone through social media can portray themselves socially as a particular style/ look/ aesthetic/ type of character where as in their sense of self they may be completely different. This example though of the use of social media for a sense of persona in social situations can backfire and do the complete opposite; Someone may have a sense of self being X and wanting to portray themselves as X through instagram; through there efforts though they could be watched and received as Z- not what they aimed for. This use of peer surveillance through social media means that the individuals audience (society) all has different experiences and backgrounds meaning their use of manipulating themselves on social media can be effects depending on these factors. This idea of self manipulation of the online world led me to research Robbie Cooper and his work ‘Alter Ego: Avatars and their Creators’. His creation explores the people behind gaming avatars and the link of their creation versus himself, although instagram isn’t gaming I feel like relates greatly in the way we can sit at home by ourself and manipulate images into something ultimately so unreal it isn’t us.
This idea then led to the exploration further of manipulation of a persons self online through the likes of facetune which is now wildly popular but also the surveillance people and celebrities who use this are under. An example of this would be the newly popular expose accounts such as @beauty.false. This type of instagram account will take images influencers posts online and not only compare them to photos of the influencer in normal day/ without lighting filters etc, but they also have started pointing out ethical issues. This falls under many umbrellas including what image / goals they give off to impressionable audiences, how an influencer looks in real life compared to their obvious photoshop and editing plus discussing and showing the likes of the new trend of ‘black fishing’ thats been noted among influencers.
Black fishing is when someone who is white manipulates themself online (and also in real life) to have what society deems the attractive attributes of a black woman. This includes having golden brown skin, curly hair, big lips, big hips and appropriating cultural practices they do (e.g hairstyles that have been used over years to keep black hair in top condition such as cornrows). The reason I believe not only this relates to the theme of surveillance in terms of sense of selves, is due to the fact these accounts take into consideration why these celebrities may photoshop or manipulate a certain image and instead of bashing them to a social presence such as ‘cancel culture and exposing culture’ now does, but instead educates a presence that this isn’t reality and the influencers sense of self is warped thus making them want to manipulate their social self into their own ideal. This type of account has now socially become a trend, meaning lots of other people have decided to make their own expose style accounts to watch these influencers under a microscope.
This type of body manipulation via apps like facetune works in a number of levels- mainly by creating unrealistic goals for passive yet influential audiences but also: by getting the original picture before the likes of facetune; you can manipulate the model by angles and lighting. When posting online; were all guilty for wanting to get the best picture possible- we all want to look nice, but what do we deem as nice? The more an audience surveils an influencer- they will pick up common trends amongst a group of celebs. The biggest example of this would be the Kardashians, when Kylie Jenner was noted to have larger hips and a bigger bum than usual contrasting to her tiny waist, many people were in awe and confusion meaning it was a large discussion and several articles going viral (such as the daily mail) for bringing this subject to light. Because she is attractive and reposted everywhere- this ideal body became a trend. people started getting butt implants and silicone in their hips to achieve this look. When this became a trend influencers were called ‘insta baddies’ for following this crowd. Not everyone has the means to afford this which lead to the over use of facetune and photoshop to create this figure, leading again to how ‘exposing’ accounts found their first subject. This surveillance of someones social self persona lead to a massive trend that is still going on today and leading to false hopes and goals people strive to achieve.
In conclusion I feel like due to social media and how were all under surveillance by not only our followers but society, The gap between an individuals sense of self versus their social self in widening and becoming more apparent which I find uncomfortable and like a Black Mirror episode in real life. The two contrast and can be swapped around with one another in different situations but in reality what we see online isn’t a real projection of someone: wether its their aesthetic, life, style, body, personality anreven race. Instagram culture in my eyes has become very damaging in creating a false sense of reality where our online social personas create their own highlight real narrative of their life: Instagram posts aren’t real and will never be ‘us’.